This page documents Hasan Piker's involvement in Abdul El-Sayed's 2026 campaign for the U.S. Senate in Michigan, criticism of their political association, and El-Sayed's subsequent public distancing and reported private intervention concerning Piker's rhetoric.
Hasan Piker became a prominent online supporter of Abdul El-Sayed during El-Sayed's campaign for the Democratic nomination in the 2026 United States Senate election in Michigan. Piker hosted El-Sayed on his livestream, appeared with him at campaign rallies, encouraged his audience to support the campaign, and attended El-Sayed's election-night watch party.[1][2]
Their association generated repeated political and media criticism. Several Democratic politicians, Jewish organizations, El-Sayed's primary opponents, and later Republican groups criticized El-Sayed for campaigning with Piker, citing statements by Piker concerning Israel, Jews, Hamas, and the September 11 attacks.[3]
El-Sayed did not end the relationship during the Democratic primary, but repeatedly rejected specific remarks by Piker while resisting calls for a broader disavowal. After winning the primary, he used increasingly direct language to separate his own campaign from Piker, stating that "nobody speaks for this campaign besides me and my campaign spokespeople" and later saying that he had "no plans" to campaign with Piker again.[4][5][6]
In September, El-Sayed continued rejecting specific Piker statements while defending his decision to speak to Piker's audience. At a Fox 2 Detroit forum, he said that he had disavowed Piker's comments concerning Jewish Americans and Jewish Michiganders "entirely."[7]
On October 7, CNN reported that El-Sayed privately warned Piker that his rhetoric was costing him votes and asked him to stop.[8]
- 1 Brief Campaign Involvement
- 2 Timeline of Backlash and Distancing
- 3 Initial Backlash Over Piker Campaign Rallies
- 4 April 7: El-Sayed Rejects Piker's September 11 Remark
- 5 April 7: El-Sayed Declines a Broad Disavowal
- 6 El-Sayed Continues Defending the Association
- 7 July 2: CNN Questions El-Sayed Again
- 8 Backlash Immediately Before and After the Primary
- 9 Republican 9/11 Claim and FactCheck.org Correction
- 10 John Fetterman Calls for El-Sayed to Separate from Piker
- 11 August 5: El-Sayed Declines to Renounce Piker
- 12 August 6: "It's Not Mine"
- 13 August 9: El-Sayed Calls the 9/11 Remark "Dumb"
- 14 August Comments Concerning American Jews and Jeremy Moss
- 15 August 24: El-Sayed Separates Piker from the Campaign
- 16 Criticism That El-Sayed Had Not Gone Far Enough
- 17 August 26: El-Sayed Says He Has "No Plans" to Campaign With Piker
- 18 September: Continued Distancing and Defense of Engagement
- 19 October: Further Distancing and Reported Private Warning
- 20 Extent of El-Sayed's Distancing
- 21 Media Treatment of the Relationship
- 22 Documented El-Sayed Responses
- 23 Published Coverage
- 24 References
Brief Campaign Involvement
El-Sayed appeared in person on Piker's livestream on January 15, 2026.[9]
Their collaboration became much more public on April 7, when Piker joined El-Sayed for campaign rallies at Michigan State University and the University of Michigan. Coverage of the events showed Piker promoting El-Sayed's candidacy and the two appearing together before large student audiences.[10]
Piker continued supporting El-Sayed through the August Democratic primary. The Wall Street Journal later described Piker as a major campaign surrogate and reported that he attended El-Sayed's election-night watch party. The newspaper also quoted El-Sayed describing Piker as useful for reaching voters who were not being reached through conventional political media.[11]
As the campaign progressed, reporters repeatedly asked El-Sayed whether Piker's statements reflected his own views.
Timeline of Backlash and Distancing
| Date | Development | El-Sayed's response | Nature of response |
|---|---|---|---|
| April 7, 2026 | During a Fox & Friends interview, El-Sayed is asked about Piker's 2019 statement that America "deserved 9/11." | El-Sayed says he does not believe the September 11 attacks were justified and argues that appearing with someone does not mean agreeing with everything they have said. | Rejects specific remark |
| April 7, 2026 | Later that day, a reporter asks generally whether Piker holds views El-Sayed disavows. | El-Sayed says he is not there to "disavow people's views" and criticizes what he describes as platform policing and cancel culture. | Declines general disavowal |
| July 2, 2026 | CNN again asks El-Sayed about Piker's September 11 statement. | El-Sayed again rejects the statement but says he is grateful for issues on which he and Piker agree. | Rejects remark, defends association |
| August 5, 2026 | After the primary, CNN asks whether El-Sayed will renounce Piker following criticism from Sen. John Fetterman. | El-Sayed says he is more concerned with the people he is campaigning to than the people campaigning with him. | Declines to renounce Piker |
| August 6, 2026 | MSNBC asks El-Sayed about Piker's advice concerning Democrats who had opposed him during the primary. | El-Sayed says Piker has his own perspective and adds that it is "not mine." | Separates his position from Piker's |
| August 6, 2026 | MSNBC asks whether El-Sayed will continue campaigning with Piker. | El-Sayed does not give a yes-or-no answer and says he is focused on whom he is campaigning for. | Leaves future appearances open |
| August 9, 2026 | NBC's Meet the Press again asks El-Sayed about Piker's September 11 remark. | El-Sayed calls it a "dumb statement" and says America did not deserve the attacks. | Explicitly rejects remark |
| August 24, 2026 | Piker faces criticism over comments concerning Israel, American Jews and Michigan state Sen. Jeremy Moss. | El-Sayed condemns antisemitism and states that nobody other than himself and campaign spokespeople speaks for his campaign. | Separates campaign from Piker |
| August 26, 2026 | Semafor asks El-Sayed about future campaign appearances with Piker. | El-Sayed says he has "no plans" to campaign with Piker again and describes the effort to make the race about a streamer as a distraction. | Says no plans to campaign with Piker |
| September 3, 2026 | El-Sayed discusses Piker during an interview with Stephen A. Smith. | El-Sayed says he does not want to reject Piker's audience and argues that speaking with Piker gives him a way to reach roughly three million listeners. | Defends engagement with Piker's audience |
| September 13, 2026 | CBS's Face the Nation asks El-Sayed about his current relationship with Piker. | El-Sayed describes Piker as a "streamer in California" and repeatedly redirects the interview toward issues affecting Michigan voters. | Further distances campaign from Piker |
| September 15, 2026 | During a Fox 2 Detroit forum, El-Sayed is asked whether he will disavow offensive comments made by Piker. | El-Sayed answers affirmatively and says that he had disavowed Piker's comments concerning Jewish Americans and Jewish Michiganders "entirely." | Explicitly disavows specific comments |
| September 17, 2026 | Axios publishes Piker's statement that the United States is worse than al-Qaeda "pound for pound" when considering terrorism and deaths. | El-Sayed says he disagrees with the statement and again describes Piker as a streamer in California. | Rejects new Piker remark |
| October 7, 2026 (report; call undated) | CNN reports a private call. | El-Sayed reportedly warned of lost votes and asked Piker to stop. | Reported private intervention[12] |
Initial Backlash Over Piker Campaign Rallies
The April rallies drew criticism before they took place.
The Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported that El-Sayed's Democratic primary opponents, several Jewish organizations, and other Democratic figures objected to the appearances because of statements Piker had previously made concerning Jews and Israel.[13]
Democratic Criticism
Representative Brad Schneider criticized the planned appearances and publicly characterized Piker as an "unapologetic antisemite."[14]
El-Sayed's primary opponent Haley Stevens similarly criticized El-Sayed's decision to campaign with Piker, citing rhetoric she regarded as antisemitic.[15]
Another primary opponent, Mallory McMorrow, also condemned the planned appearances and compared the political problem posed by Piker's rhetoric to controversies surrounding far-right streamer Nick Fuentes.[16]
Senator Elissa Slotkin additionally criticized El-Sayed's decision to appear with Piker.[17]
These criticisms concerned El-Sayed's decision to appear with Piker; the association alone did not establish that El-Sayed shared Piker's views.
Jewish Organizations
The Michigan State University chapter of Hillel said it was "deeply troubled" by Piker's scheduled appearance and described him as a "known antisemite."[18]
Jonathan Greenblatt, CEO of the Anti-Defamation League, also criticized El-Sayed for campaigning with Piker.[19]
Piker has disputed accusations that he is antisemitic and has argued that critics frequently conflate his opposition to Israel and Zionism with hostility toward Jews.[20]
Carrie Rheingans Withdraws
Michigan state Representative Carrie Rheingans, who had been expected to participate in the April rallies, withdrew before the events.
JTA reported that Rheingans continued to endorse El-Sayed but cited concerns expressed by Jewish constituents and her own objections to statements Piker had made.[21]
Her withdrawal was an early example of the political fallout surrounding Piker's participation.
April 7: El-Sayed Rejects Piker's September 11 Remark
On the morning of the April rallies, El-Sayed appeared on Fox & Friends and was asked specifically about Piker's 2019 statement that America "deserved 9/11."
El-Sayed rejected the statement. FactCheck.org quoted him saying that he did not believe the September 11 attacks were justified and that appearing with someone did not mean agreeing with everything that person had said.[22]
That answer later became relevant when political advertisements portrayed El-Sayed as unwilling to reject the statement.
FactCheck.org concluded that there was no evidence El-Sayed himself believed America deserved the September 11 attacks and documented multiple occasions on which he stated the opposite.[23]
April 7: El-Sayed Declines a Broad Disavowal
Later on April 7, El-Sayed was asked a more general question about whether Piker held any views he would disavow.
El-Sayed responded:
"I'm not here to disavow people's views."
— Abdul El-Sayed, April 7, 2026
He described the questioning as "platform policing" and "cancel culture," then returned to his campaign's policy agenda.[24]
The two April 7 exchanges addressed different questions. In the first, El-Sayed was specifically asked about September 11 and rejected Piker's remark. In the second, he was asked whether he would generally disavow Piker's views and declined a broader repudiation.
FactCheck.org later noted this distinction when evaluating political advertising that presented the latter exchange as evidence that El-Sayed had refused to reject Piker's September 11 remark.[25]
El-Sayed Continues Defending the Association
Despite the criticism, El-Sayed proceeded with both April 7 rallies.
At the University of Michigan event, JTA reported that El-Sayed mocked the amount of political and media attention being devoted to whether he would campaign with Piker.[26]
El-Sayed also told the outlet that he opposed antisemitism while distinguishing antisemitism from criticism of the Israeli government and pro-Israel political organizations.[27]
El-Sayed continued to argue that Piker's audience was politically valuable to the campaign.
The Wall Street Journal later quoted El-Sayed saying that Piker was reaching people other political media were not reaching and that young attendees told him they had learned of his candidacy through Piker.[28]
July 2: CNN Questions El-Sayed Again
CNN's Kasie Hunt returned to the subject during a July 2 interview.
Asked whether he agreed with Piker's September 11 statement, El-Sayed again said that he did not.
He emphasized that voters could hold him responsible for his own words and actions and said that he did not agree with everything said by everyone who campaigned with him.[29]
El-Sayed also defended the value of appearing with Piker, saying there were many issues on which they agreed and arguing that online creators allowed the campaign to reach people outside traditional political media.[30]
The interview left the basic relationship intact: El-Sayed rejected the September 11 remark but did not repudiate Piker.
Backlash Immediately Before and After the Primary
As the August Democratic primary approached, Piker's growing role in progressive Democratic politics drew additional national criticism.
Democratic strategist James Carville publicly criticized Piker's influence within the party. Piker and El-Sayed subsequently mocked Carville during an online conversation shortly before the primary.[31]
El-Sayed won the Democratic nomination on August 4. By the following day, the association with Piker had already become an issue in the general-election campaign.[32]
Republican 9/11 Claim and FactCheck.org Correction
On August 5, Republican nominee Mike Rogers issued a statement claiming that El-Sayed believed America deserved the September 11 attacks.
FactCheck.org investigated the statement and found that Rogers had provided no evidence that El-Sayed held that belief.[33]
According to FactCheck.org, Rogers' campaign pointed instead to El-Sayed's association with Piker and to an April exchange in which El-Sayed had declined a general invitation to disavow Piker's views.
The National Republican Senatorial Committee made a similar argument in an advertisement stating that El-Sayed had refused to disavow Piker after Piker's September 11 remark.
FactCheck.org noted that the advertisement conflated two separate exchanges: El-Sayed's refusal to offer a general disavowal and his separate, explicit rejection of the September 11 remark.[34]
FactCheck.org emphasized that El-Sayed had repeatedly rejected Piker's September 11 statement.
John Fetterman Calls for El-Sayed to Separate from Piker
Democratic Senator John Fetterman became one of the most prominent members of his own party to criticize the association after the primary.
Fetterman argued that El-Sayed's appearances with Piker could become a liability in the general election and challenged him to continue campaigning with Piker if he believed otherwise.[35]
Fetterman's argument was that the association itself created a recurring political liability, even when El-Sayed rejected the specific statements at issue.
August 5: El-Sayed Declines to Renounce Piker
CNN's Kaitlan Collins asked El-Sayed on August 5 whether he would renounce Piker, referring to Fetterman's criticism.
El-Sayed did not agree to do so. Instead, he said he was less concerned with people campaigning alongside him than with the voters to whom he was campaigning.[36]
El-Sayed again declined to cut ties, while keeping the focus on his own campaign rather than Piker's statements.
August 6: "It's Not Mine"
El-Sayed used sharper language to separate his own campaign from Piker the following day.
During an appearance on MSNBC's All In, interviewer Jacob Soboroff played El-Sayed a clip in which Piker criticized Democrats who had opposed El-Sayed during the primary and argued that those Democrats should not expect El-Sayed to be responsible for repairing the relationship.
Asked whether Piker's advice was helpful, El-Sayed described Piker as a streamer with his own perspective and said:
"It's not mine."
— Abdul El-Sayed, August 6, 2026
El-Sayed instead said that his own approach was to seek every vote and rebuild trust with voters who had supported other candidates.[37]
Unlike his earlier answers, which centered on the September 11 remark, this response separated El-Sayed's general-election political strategy from Piker's commentary about the campaign.
Asked Whether He Would Campaign With Piker Again
Soboroff then directly asked whether El-Sayed intended to continue campaigning with Piker.
El-Sayed did not answer yes or no. He instead said that he was focused on campaigning throughout Michigan and on the people he was campaigning for rather than whom he was campaigning with.[38]
He still stopped short of saying that Piker would no longer appear with the campaign.
August 9: El-Sayed Calls the 9/11 Remark "Dumb"
El-Sayed was again questioned about Piker on NBC's Meet the Press on August 9.
Asked whether he disavowed Piker's September 11 remark, El-Sayed responded affirmatively and described it as a "dumb statement." He also explicitly stated that America did not deserve the September 11 attacks.[39]
FactCheck.org cited this interview, alongside El-Sayed's April statements, when concluding that claims portraying El-Sayed himself as believing America deserved September 11 were unsupported.[40]
This was a more direct public criticism of the September 11 remark, but El-Sayed still did not announce a break with Piker.
August Comments Concerning American Jews and Jeremy Moss
A new round of criticism followed comments Piker made during an August livestream concerning Israel, American Jewish organizations, and Michigan Democratic politician Jeremy Moss.
The Associated Press reported that Piker argued that presenting American Jews as uniformly invested in Israel could contribute to antisemitic backlash against Jewish Americans. Piker later maintained that he had been warning against the possibility of antisemitic violence rather than advocating or excusing it.[41]
Several politicians and organizations interpreted the remarks differently and publicly criticized Piker.
Individual Public Responses
The following table records public criticism of Piker and his political associations, including responses preceding the August controversy. Descriptions of alleged misconduct are attributed to the speakers making those accusations rather than presented as independently established facts.
| Date | Person | Response | Original post / clip |
|---|---|---|---|
| April 29, 2026 | Rep. Mike Lawler | Lawler joined Rep. Josh Gottheimer in introducing H.Res. 1239, a bipartisan resolution condemning what it described as antisemitic rhetoric from prominent online personalities, specifically naming Piker and Candace Owens. | H.Res. 1239 |
| August 13, 2026 | Rep. Haley Stevens | Stevens said Piker "should be condemned," adding that she did not believe he was part of the Democratic Party. She later called on El-Sayed to end his affiliation with Piker as he moved into the general election. | Fox News |
| August 18, 2026 | Rep. Jared Moskowitz | After defeating Oliver Larkin, a primary challenger supported by Piker, Moskowitz publicly taunted the streamer, writing, "My condolences to @hasanthehun." In subsequent interviews, Moskowitz said he wanted nothing to do with Piker and argued that Piker and the Democratic Socialists of America could not "coexist" with him politically. | X |
| August 23, 2026 | Mike Rogers | Rogers called Piker's remarks "absolutely DISGUSTING" and demanded that El-Sayed "call this out and disavow Hasan Piker once and for all." Rogers also characterized Piker's comments concerning Jeremy Moss and American Jews as a call for violence. | X |
| August 23, 2026 | Rep. Josh Gottheimer | Gottheimer accused Piker's rhetoric of inciting hostility toward American Jews and called on Democrats to condemn his views, adding that candidates who campaigned with him were part of the political problem. | X |
| August 24, 2026 | Rep. Hillary Scholten | Scholten issued a formal statement criticizing Piker's remarks concerning American Jews and Jeremy Moss and arguing that such rhetoric had no place in Michigan politics. | X |
| August 24, 2026 | Rep. Hillary Scholten | After Piker responded to her criticism, Scholten posted a separate reply arguing that Piker, rather than Scholten, was harming Democratic prospects in November. | X |
| August 24, 2026 | House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries | Jeffries described the claim that American Jews were inviting violence against themselves as dangerous and antisemitic and stated that there was no justification for threats against Jewish Americans. | X |
| August 24, 2026 | Jeremy Moss | Moss issued a statement saying there was no room for extremism in Michigan and rejected the suggestion that Michigan's Jewish community was responsible for antisemitic harm directed against it. | X |
| August 24, 2026 | Rep. Susie Lee | Lee stated that claims blaming American Jews for violence against their communities were unacceptable and antisemitic. | X |
| August 24, 2026 | Andrew Cuomo | Cuomo condemned Piker's rhetoric and called on Democrats who had embraced or elevated him to publicly reject the comments. | X |
| August 24, 2026 | Jonathan Greenblatt | The Anti-Defamation League CEO questioned whether public figures associating with Piker were familiar with his streams and criticized a series of Piker's statements and characterizations. | X |
| August 25, 2026 | House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries | In a CNN interview, Jeffries said he would continue speaking out against Piker's comments concerning the Jewish community, saying, "I've just addressed Hasan Piker's comments as it relates to the Jewish community as forcefully as I can, and I will continue to do that." | PollTracker2024 clip |
| August 25, 2026 | Rep. Josh Gottheimer | Gottheimer wrote that telling Jewish Americans they were bringing violence on themselves was "blatantly antisemitic" and argued that anyone who campaigned with or elevated Piker was complicit in rising antisemitism and anti-American hatred. | X |
| August 25, 2026 | Sen. Jacky Rosen | Rosen said Piker had been "trafficking in antisemitic tropes for a while" and called his remarks about Jewish Americans a "new low." She argued that blaming Jewish Americans for violence directed at them could provide an excuse for anti-Jewish hate crimes and stated that crimes against Jews for being Jewish are antisemitism. | X |
| August 25, 2026 | Rep. Josh Gottheimer | In a television appearance, Gottheimer called Piker an antisemite, said nobody should campaign with or repost him, and said he and Rep. Mike Lawler had a resolution to condemn Piker when Congress returned. | Acyn clip |
| August 25, 2026 | Rep. Josh Gottheimer | In an interview with CNN's Dana Bash, Gottheimer said Piker "should be put outside and not welcomed into any kind of tent" in the Democratic Party. | CNN / Inside Politics clip |
| August 25, 2026 | Rep. Brad Schneider | Schneider said political leaders should oppose hate and violence and introduced a statement criticizing Piker's remarks. He described Piker's comments as a "call to violence against American Jews." | X |
| August 25, 2026 | Joel Rubin | In a Fox News interview, Rubin called for Democrats to reject Piker, saying, "We need to shame this man, get him out of our party, get him out of campaigning with candidates." When asked about the Democratic Party's "big tent," Rubin added, "I don't wanna be in the tent with the guy who's trying to kill me." | Fox News clip |
| August 25, 2026 | Ken Martin | Martin distinguished criticism of the Israeli government from blaming American Jews for hatred or violence directed at them, calling the latter "dangerous, wrong, and antisemitic." He added that no Jewish American should be held responsible for the actions of a foreign government and said antisemitism should be confronted with "zero tolerance." | X |
| August 25, 2026 | Andrew Kolvet | Kolvet mocked El-Sayed's public statements condemning antisemitism after the controversy surrounding Piker, describing Piker as El-Sayed's "little henchman" and accusing Piker of saying that "eventually someone is going to come around and take action" against Jewish Michigan Democrat Jeremy Moss. | X |
| August 25, 2026 | Sen. Elissa Slotkin | Slotkin responded to Piker's comments by saying no community should face threats of violence because of its political views and argued that "blaming the victims of violence for bringing it on themselves only further endangers people." She also pointed to rising antisemitism and the recent attack at Temple Israel in Michigan as reasons public figures should avoid suggesting that Jews or others are responsible for being targeted. | X |
| August 25, 2026 | Sen. Cory Booker | Booker said Piker's language targeting Jewish Americans was "dangerous and hateful" and had no place in civic discourse. He said suggesting that Jewish Americans bear responsibility for hatred or violence directed against them was "wrong, dangerous, and antisemitic." | X |
| August 25, 2026 | Rep. Josh Gottheimer | Gottheimer referenced the bipartisan antisemitism resolution he introduced with Rep. Mike Lawler in April and said Piker's recent comments demonstrated why the measure was necessary. He criticized Piker for telling a large audience that Jews who support the U.S.-Israel relationship bear responsibility for hostility directed against them. | X |
| August 25, 2026 | Rep. Hillary Scholten | During remarks carried by C-SPAN, Scholten said, "I do not support the comments of Hasan Piker," and added that Piker had said "some terrible things about America, about American troops." | C-SPAN clip |
| August 25, 2026 | Rep. Pete Aguilar | Aguilar said comments blaming American Jews for threats directed against them were "incredibly harmful and dangerous." He added that political leaders should oppose violence, hate, and antisemitism wherever they appear. | X |
| August 25, 2026 | Rep. Brad Sherman | Sherman accused Piker of attempting to "encourage and justify violence against American Jews" and of suggesting that, if violence occurred, responsibility would lie with Jewish Americans who publicly support Israel. | X |
| August 25, 2026 | Rep. Ritchie Torres | Torres said there was "absolutely no justification for antisemitism" and accused Piker of victim-blaming American Jews. He argued that responsibility for antisemitic violence rests with those who commit it rather than with Jewish Americans targeted by it. | Jewish Insider |
| August 25, 2026 | Rep. Greg Stanton | Stanton said that framing violence against Jewish Americans as something they had brought upon themselves shifted responsibility "from the perpetrators onto the very people they want to harm." | Jewish Insider |
| August 25, 2026 | Micah Lasher | Lasher accused Piker of crossing the line between criticism of Israel and what he described as "Jew hatred of the ancient variety." He argued that attacks on Jews for supporting Israel targeted a core part of their Jewish identity and said Piker's rhetoric encouraged such hostility. | X |
| August 26, 2026 | Rep. Debbie Dingell | Dingell said she "strongly disagree[d]" with many of Piker's statements, citing his rhetoric concerning Israel and comments about rape, which she called "simply inexcusable." She said El-Sayed should make clear that he disagreed with Piker and added that she hoped Piker would not return to Michigan before the election. | CNN transcript |
| August 26, 2026 | Rep. Jimmy Panetta | Panetta said the suggestion that Jewish Americans who publicly support Israel bear responsibility for violence against the broader Jewish community was "wrong, reckless, and antisemitic." He argued that Piker's rhetoric gave cover to people committing anti-Jewish hate crimes and said political disagreement could never justify violence against individuals or communities. | X profile — specific post link needed |
| August 26, 2026 | Sen. John Fetterman | Fetterman criticized the relationship between El-Sayed and Piker, describing it as a "bromance" centered on "defending Hamas" and what he called "a parade of deeply antisemitic rhetoric." He also shared a National Review article titled "No Daylight Between Abdul El-Sayed and Hasan Piker." | X |
| August 27, 2026 | Sen. Jon Ossoff | Through a spokesperson, Ossoff said he "unreservedly rejects reckless and dangerous rhetoric suggesting that policy advocacy invites violence against the Jewish community or any community." He added that American Jews and all Americans should be able to advocate for their views without fear of reprisal. | Atlanta Journal-Constitution |
| August 27, 2026 | Rep. Lisa McClain | McClain accused Piker of being "antisemitic and dangerous" after referencing his remark that people could "take action" against American Jews who support Israel. She also argued that Democrats politically "own" Piker and presented him as representative of the party. | X |
| August 27, 2026 | Rep. Josh Schriver | Schriver accused Piker of wanting him and his family to be killed, calling Piker "our enemy." He added that people should pray for Piker and for those who wish to persecute them. | X |
| August 27, 2026 | Rep. Jake Auchincloss | Auchincloss said he had previously rejected Piker's rhetoric and, following Piker's recent remarks concerning American Jews, called on "every Democrat" to condemn what he described as Piker's "hate against Jews." Auchincloss characterized the remarks as a "call to violence against an American Jew." | X |
| August 27, 2026 | Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel | Nessel criticized Abdul El-Sayed's response to the controversy surrounding Piker and argued that El-Sayed's rhetoric was contributing to increased antisemitism. Her remarks were circulated in a video clip by DSA Watch. | Clip |
| August 27, 2026 | Rep. Randy Fine | Fine accused Democrats of embracing Piker and then objecting when questioned about him. He also accused Piker of supporting terrorism and wanting Republicans dead, and called for Piker to be "out of America." | X |
| August 27, 2026 | Rep. Brad Sherman | Sherman again criticized Piker, this time accusing him of having "advocated raping little girls." Sherman further alleged that Piker had "rejoiced on October 7" when Hamas carried out its attack. These were Sherman's accusations, not findings established by the post itself. | X |
| August 27, 2026 | Lara Trump | Trump criticized Democrats for continuing to associate with Piker and contrasted their response with how she said the MAGA movement handles controversial figures. She said conservatives had encountered "some crazies" but had been quick to distance themselves from such individuals, saying, "This is not a MAGA person." | Clip |
The entries above describe the speakers' own public responses. Where a link is hosted by an aggregator account such as PollTracker2024 or Acyn, the listed respondent is the person speaking in the clip rather than the account that posted it.
Piker disputed claims that his remarks justified or encouraged violence and maintained that he was warning that conflating Jewish identity with the Israeli state could increase antisemitic danger.[42]
August 24: El-Sayed Separates Piker from the Campaign
El-Sayed responded on August 24 with a statement addressing Piker's remarks.
El-Sayed posted the statement under the heading "My statement on Hasan Piker's comments regarding Jeremy Moss."[43]
El-Sayed condemned antisemitism and said Americans should be able to advocate for their political beliefs without fear of violence.
He then stated:
"Nobody speaks for this campaign besides me and my campaign spokespeople."
— Abdul El-Sayed, August 24, 2026
El-Sayed also criticized what he described as an effort by politicians and pundits to make the Senate campaign about a Twitch streamer rather than issues such as healthcare, education and the cost of living.[44]
The Associated Press described the statement as El-Sayed distancing himself from Piker's comments.[45]
Piker subsequently characterized El-Sayed's statement as neutral and said that criticism of his original remarks had misrepresented his argument.[46]
Criticism That El-Sayed Had Not Gone Far Enough
El-Sayed's August 24 statement did not end criticism of the relationship.
Republican opponent Mike Rogers argued that the response was inadequate and accused El-Sayed of refusing to disavow Piker.[47]
Democratic strategist Tré Easton likewise argued that El-Sayed needed to distance himself from Piker more clearly because he considered the association a foreseeable general-election liability.[48]
Neither criticism established that Piker held an official campaign role. El-Sayed's August 24 statement expressly said that Piker did not speak on behalf of his campaign.
August 26: El-Sayed Says He Has "No Plans" to Campaign With Piker
Two days after his statement separating Piker from the campaign, El-Sayed gave a more direct answer about whether they would continue appearing together.
In an August 26 interview with Semafor, El-Sayed said that he had "no plans" to campaign with Piker again.[49]
El-Sayed also argued that the controversy was distracting from issues he considered more relevant to Michigan voters and referred to Piker as a streamer in Los Angeles.[50]
The answer went further than El-Sayed's August 24 statement. Rather than only stating that Piker did not speak for the campaign, El-Sayed now said he did not plan to campaign with him again.
September: Continued Distancing and Defense of Engagement
El-Sayed continued to separate his own campaign from Piker in September, while also defending his decision to speak to Piker's audience.
September 3: El-Sayed Defends Speaking to Piker's Audience
During an interview with Stephen A. Smith, El-Sayed said that he did not want to reject the roughly three million people who listened to Piker. He argued that speaking with Piker allowed him to offer those listeners a route into electoral politics while reiterating that he did not agree with everything Piker said.[51]
The comments showed that El-Sayed's distancing from Piker did not amount to a rejection of engaging with Piker's audience.
September 13: "A Streamer in California"
During a September 13 appearance on CBS's Face the Nation, El-Sayed was asked about his current relationship with Piker.
El-Sayed did not describe an ongoing campaign relationship and instead referred to Piker as a "streamer in California." He argued that Republicans were trying to make the Senate race about Piker rather than issues such as affordability in Michigan.[52]
When asked why he had condemned antisemitism without directly calling out Piker's rhetoric, El-Sayed objected to the repeated focus on Piker and again redirected the discussion toward issues affecting Michigan voters.[53]
Later in the interview, however, El-Sayed again cited his conversation with Piker as an example of his willingness to speak to audiences outside his existing political coalition, noting that Piker had an audience of roughly three million people.[54]
September 15: El-Sayed Says He "Disavowed" Piker's Comments
El-Sayed used more explicit language at a Fox 2 Detroit forum on September 15.
Asked whether he would "100 percent disavow" offensive comments made by Piker, El-Sayed answered affirmatively. He said that when Piker made comments concerning Jewish Americans and Jewish Michiganders, he had "disavowed them entirely."[55]
El-Sayed again distinguished between Piker and Piker's audience, saying that the reason he spoke with Piker was the approximately three million people who paid attention to him.[56]
The exchange was one of El-Sayed's clearest public statements disavowing specific comments made by Piker while continuing to defend his decision to engage with Piker's audience.
September 17: El-Sayed Rejects Piker's America–al-Qaeda Comparison
Piker generated renewed criticism after telling Axios that he believed the United States was worse than al-Qaeda "pound for pound" when considering terrorism and deaths around the world.
In reporting published September 17, El-Sayed rejected the comparison when asked about it by Axios, saying that he disagreed with Piker's statement.[57]
El-Sayed again characterized Piker as a streamer in California and redirected attention toward his own campaign and the policies of his Republican opponent.[58]
October: Further Distancing and Reported Private Warning
October 5 Profile: Piker Responds to El-Sayed's Distancing
In a profile published on October 5, 2026, New York writer Simon van Zuylen-Wood asked Piker whether he felt abandoned by El-Sayed. In the September interview, Piker accepted the distancing and said he still trusted El-Sayed to pursue accountability for Israel as a senator.[59]
October 7 Report: Private Warning About Lost Votes
On October 7, 2026, CNN's Edward-Isaac Dovere reported that El-Sayed had recently called Piker, warned that his rhetoric was costing him votes, and asked him to stop. CNN attributed the account to two unnamed people whom El-Sayed had told about the conversation. Piker did not respond to CNN's requests for comment.[60]
The report did not date the call or quantify lost support. It describes a reported private warning, not a recorded public quotation or independently measured electoral effect.
Extent of El-Sayed's Distancing
The record documents several different forms of distancing: rejection of individual statements, separation of Piker's commentary from the campaign's official positions, and withdrawal from further joint campaigning.
- In April, El-Sayed rejected Piker's September 11 statement while defending his willingness to campaign with people with whom he did not completely agree.
- Later that day, he declined requests for a broader disavowal.
- In July, he again rejected the September 11 statement while defending areas of political agreement with Piker.
- On August 5, he declined a direct request to renounce Piker.
- On August 6, he said Piker's advice concerning the general-election campaign was "not mine."
- On August 9, he described Piker's September 11 remark as a "dumb statement."
- On August 24, he stated that Piker did not speak for his campaign.
- On August 26, he said he had "no plans" to campaign with Piker again.
- On September 3, he defended speaking to Piker's audience while reiterating that he did not agree with everything Piker said.
- On September 13, he repeatedly characterized Piker as a streamer in California and argued that Piker should not be the focus of the Senate campaign.
- On September 15, he said that he had "disavowed" Piker's comments concerning Jewish Americans and Jewish Michiganders "entirely."
- In reporting published September 17, he rejected Piker's comparison of the United States with al-Qaeda.
- CNN's October 7 report described a private electoral warning.
Taken together, El-Sayed's statements show a more substantial separation between his campaign and Piker than was evident immediately after the primary. He rejected specific remarks, stated that Piker did not speak for the campaign, and said that he did not plan to campaign with him again.[61][62]
The cited reporting does not establish that El-Sayed ended all personal contact with Piker, formally rejected his endorsement, or that Piker withdrew his support. Piker's response in the October profile expressed continued confidence in El-Sayed despite the distancing.[63]
Media Treatment of the Relationship
By the general election, media coverage often treated Piker's involvement as an ongoing issue for El-Sayed rather than a one-off campaign endorsement.
In April, the Associated Press and JTA covered disagreement among Democrats and Jewish organizations over El-Sayed's decision to campaign with Piker.[64][65]
After the primary, The Wall Street Journal described Piker as an important surrogate for El-Sayed while also documenting criticism of Piker within the Democratic Party.[66]
FactCheck.org subsequently examined Republican attempts to associate El-Sayed with Piker's September 11 remark and found no evidence supporting the claim that El-Sayed himself believed America deserved the attacks.[67]
Following the later controversy concerning American Jews and Jeremy Moss, the Associated Press reported that the relationship could complicate El-Sayed's effort to unify Democrats during the general election and described his August 24 statement as an attempt to distance himself from Piker's comments.[68]
On August 26, Semafor reported that El-Sayed had gone further by saying he had "no plans" to campaign with Piker again.[69]
September coverage continued to focus on the distinction between El-Sayed's distancing from Piker himself and his defense of speaking to Piker's audience. Forbes reported El-Sayed's argument that he wanted to reach Piker's roughly three million listeners, while CBS later questioned him about the current relationship on Face the Nation.[70][71]
JTA subsequently reported El-Sayed's September 15 statement that he had disavowed Piker's comments concerning Jewish Americans and Jewish Michiganders, and Axios reported two days later that El-Sayed rejected Piker's comparison of the United States with al-Qaeda.[72][73]
CNN's October 7 report added an account of private intervention.[74]
Documented El-Sayed Responses
| Date | Setting | Issue | Documented response | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| April 7, 2026 | Fox & Friends | Piker's September 11 statement | Rejects the remark and says appearing with someone does not mean agreeing with everything they have said. | FactCheck.org |
| April 7, 2026 | Campaign event | Asked generally which Piker views he disavows | Declines a general disavowal and criticizes platform policing and cancel culture. | FactCheck.org |
| July 2, 2026 | CNN | September 11 statement | Again rejects the remark while defending the value of appearing before Piker's audience. | CNN |
| August 5, 2026 | CNN | Asked whether he would renounce Piker | Declines to renounce him and says he is focused on voters rather than those campaigning with him. | FactCheck.org |
| August 6, 2026 | MSNBC | Piker's comments about Democrats who opposed El-Sayed | Says Piker's perspective is "not mine." | RealClearPolitics / MSNBC |
| August 6, 2026 | MSNBC | Asked if he will continue campaigning with Piker | Does not answer yes or no and redirects to his campaign for Michigan voters. | RealClearPolitics / MSNBC |
| August 9, 2026 | Meet the Press | September 11 statement | Calls the statement "dumb" and says America did not deserve September 11. | FactCheck.org |
| August 24, 2026 | Campaign statement | Piker's comments concerning American Jews and Jeremy Moss | Condemns antisemitism and says only El-Sayed and authorized campaign spokespeople speak for the campaign. | Original post · AP |
| August 26, 2026 | Semafor | Asked about future campaigning with Piker | Says he has "no plans" to campaign with Piker again and argues that the controversy is distracting from issues affecting Michigan voters. | Semafor |
| September 3, 2026 | Stephen A. Smith interview | Why he continues to engage with Piker's audience | Defends speaking to Piker's roughly three million listeners while reiterating that he does not agree with everything Piker says. | Forbes |
| September 13, 2026 | Face the Nation | Asked about his current relationship with Piker | Describes Piker as a streamer in California and redirects the discussion toward issues affecting Michigan voters. | CBS News |
| September 15, 2026 | Fox 2 Detroit forum | Asked whether he will disavow offensive comments by Piker | Says he had disavowed Piker's comments concerning Jewish Americans and Jewish Michiganders "entirely." | JTA |
| September 17, 2026 | Axios | Piker's comparison of the United States with al-Qaeda | Says he disagrees with the statement and again describes Piker as a streamer in California. | Axios |
| October 7, 2026 (publication) | Reported private call | Electoral concerns | Warning and request to stop, according to two unnamed sources. | CNN |
Published Coverage
| Date | Publication | Relevance | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| March 25, 2026 | Jewish Insider | Covers criticism from Elissa Slotkin and Haley Stevens over El-Sayed's planned appearances with Piker. | Read |
| March 26, 2026 | Jewish Insider | Covers Mallory McMorrow's criticism of El-Sayed's decision to campaign with Piker. | Read |
| April 6, 2026 | Jewish Telegraphic Agency | Covers criticism from Jewish organizations and Democratic figures before the campus rallies. | Read |
| April 8, 2026 | Jewish Telegraphic Agency | Reports from the El-Sayed/Piker rallies and covers El-Sayed's defense of the appearances. | Read |
| August 10, 2026 | FactCheck.org | Reviews El-Sayed's responses to Piker's September 11 remark and finds no evidence that El-Sayed shared that view. | Read |
| August 12, 2026 | The Wall Street Journal | Covers Piker's role as an El-Sayed surrogate and the campaign's view that he helped reach younger voters. | Read |
| August 24, 2026 | Jewish Insider | Covers criticism of Piker's remarks from Hillary Scholten, Josh Gottheimer and other elected officials. | Read |
| August 25, 2026 | Associated Press | Covers El-Sayed's August 24 statement separating Piker's commentary from the campaign, along with responses from Piker, Democrats and Republicans. | Read |
| August 26, 2026 | Semafor | Reports that El-Sayed said he had no plans to campaign with Piker again. | Read |
| September 3, 2026 | Forbes | Covers El-Sayed's defense of speaking to Piker's roughly three million listeners despite disagreements with Piker. | Read |
| September 13, 2026 | CBS News | Provides the transcript of El-Sayed's Face the Nation interview, including questions about his current relationship with Piker. | Read |
| September 16, 2026 | Jewish Telegraphic Agency | Reports El-Sayed's statement that he had disavowed Piker's comments concerning Jewish Americans and Jewish Michiganders. | Read |
| September 17, 2026 | Axios | Reports Piker's comparison of the United States with al-Qaeda and El-Sayed's rejection of the statement. | Read |
| October 5, 2026 | New York / Intelligencer | Includes Piker's response to El-Sayed's distancing. | Read |
| October 7, 2026 | CNN | Reports a private electoral warning. | Read · CNN Newsource Spanish-language syndication |
References
- ^ "Abdul El-Sayed Visits Hasan," HasanAbi Archive, January 15, 2026
- ^ Ashley Wong, "Online Agitator Hasan Piker Is Driving Democrats Up a Wall," The Wall Street Journal, August 12, 2026
- ^ Andrew Lapin, Jewish Telegraphic Agency, April 6, 2026
- ^ D'Angelo Gore, FactCheck.org, August 10, 2026
- ^ Jesse Bedayn, Associated Press, August 25, 2026
- ^ Nicholas Wu, Semafor, August 26, 2026
- ^ Jewish Telegraphic Agency, September 16, 2026
- ^ Edward-Isaac Dovere, CNN, October 7, 2026
- ^ "Abdul El-Sayed Visits Hasan," HasanAbi Archive
- ^ Andrew Lapin, Jewish Telegraphic Agency, April 8, 2026
- ^ The Wall Street Journal, August 12, 2026
- ^ CNN, October 7, 2026
- ^ Jewish Telegraphic Agency, April 6, 2026
- ^ Mediaite, March 25, 2026
- ^ Jewish Insider, March 25, 2026
- ^ Jewish Insider, March 26, 2026
- ^ Jewish Insider, March 25, 2026
- ^ Jewish Telegraphic Agency, April 6, 2026
- ^ Jewish Telegraphic Agency
- ^ Jewish Telegraphic Agency, April 27, 2026
- ^ Jewish Telegraphic Agency
- ^ FactCheck.org, August 10, 2026
- ^ FactCheck.org
- ^ FactCheck.org
- ^ FactCheck.org
- ^ Jewish Telegraphic Agency, April 8, 2026
- ^ Jewish Telegraphic Agency
- ^ The Wall Street Journal, August 12, 2026
- ^ CNN transcript, July 2, 2026
- ^ CNN transcript, July 2, 2026
- ^ Fox News, August 4, 2026
- ^ FactCheck.org, August 10, 2026
- ^ FactCheck.org
- ^ FactCheck.org
- ^ CNN, August 5, 2026
- ^ FactCheck.org
- ^ RealClearPolitics / MSNBC, August 6, 2026
- ^ RealClearPolitics / MSNBC
- ^ FactCheck.org
- ^ FactCheck.org
- ^ Associated Press, August 25, 2026
- ^ Associated Press, August 25, 2026
- ^ Abdul El-Sayed, X, August 24, 2026
- ^ Associated Press, August 25, 2026
- ^ Associated Press
- ^ Associated Press
- ^ Associated Press
- ^ Associated Press
- ^ Semafor, August 26, 2026
- ^ Semafor
- ^ Forbes, September 3, 2026
- ^ CBS News transcript, September 13, 2026
- ^ CBS News
- ^ CBS News
- ^ Jewish Telegraphic Agency, September 16, 2026
- ^ Jewish Telegraphic Agency
- ^ Axios, September 17, 2026
- ^ Axios
- ^ Simon van Zuylen-Wood, "The Inescapable Hasan Piker," New York / Intelligencer, October 5, 2026
- ^ Edward-Isaac Dovere, CNN, October 7, 2026. CNN Newsource Spanish-language syndication, KVIA, October 7, 2026.
- ^ Associated Press, August 25, 2026
- ^ Semafor, August 26, 2026
- ^ New York / Intelligencer, October 5, 2026
- ^ Associated Press, April 9, 2026
- ^ Jewish Telegraphic Agency, April 6, 2026
- ^ The Wall Street Journal, August 12, 2026
- ^ FactCheck.org
- ^ Associated Press, August 25, 2026
- ^ Semafor, August 26, 2026
- ^ Forbes, September 3, 2026
- ^ CBS News, September 13, 2026
- ^ Jewish Telegraphic Agency, September 16, 2026
- ^ Axios, September 17, 2026
- ^ CNN, October 7, 2026